You've never actually played a "high graphics" game have you? Lineage2 has arguably the best graphics out there and there is a lot of content in that game.
A storyline doesn't make a game great either, what use is a decent storyline if the gameplay is crappy?
WoW being a "high graphics" game by your definition has a huge and ultimately still progressing storyline. Every single boss in the game ties into a larger storyline, aside from the final raid bosses in each instance which are the end of a particular storyline. 8.5 million people play WoW and it's not because of the graphics, but because its ane exceptionally well executed and planned game.
Mir is a poor graphics game, yet there is no real storyline to that at all. Its like "hey some oma's invaded, and there's some temples with **** in em" then people spend 2 years killing bugs in a cave 24 hours a day and the only reason for this is the fact the bugs are there. There are no character tied into the bosses etc, its just a decision on a whim to go there and kill some ****ty boss for no reason other than the fact that once a year it might drop something good.
Before I start I just wanna say that something that is good for my taste doesn't have to match anyone else's taste, when I play I usually focus on the story and not on killing all the time.
I think you totally missed my point, my point was that I would prefer game that have better story/gameplay/community over game that have great graphics. It doesn't mean that high graphic mmorpg cannot be good at this, but usually as I said already, the developers are trying to build the story on the graphic and not the way it should be. Its not that I will not play mmorpg just because it got good graphics (well, since now my good computer has no internet, and I cannot play on it, I dont really have much choice, but thats not the point), but if I have to pick good graphic vs story/community/gameplay I will not go on graphics.
What you just said about Mir kinda sum my point, I usually don't play games that just include running after bosses and kill them, but from time to time its fun just to kill stuff, after all we are humans. Usually I prefer games that have massive amount of story. I played tibia for a long time, the quests there are crazy, huge amount of information that everything can be used somewhere, there are 170k peoples playing (and tibia was never advertised), and you can actually do a quest that no one ever done because no one found it.
True I never played WoW, but from what I saw on some sites that explains quests ect and the story, and from asking friends, Tibia has way better story, and gameplay and community. If you die in tibia you loose 2%-10% of your exp (and you can loose levels), and the backpack you have will always fall and the items you have got 10% to fall down, and lets compare it to WoW, you cannot kill someone who annoyed you, only maybe to lure stuff on him but its not exactly the same effect. The death's in tibia make it very interesting, if someone die he loose a lot, so peoples are being careful, it also giving the high levels chance to control to community at some sort of a way, so you can understand that peoples will communicate way more then in WoW.
MMORPG is built from MMO (massive multiplayer online) RPG (role playing game) and in both I think tibia is beating WoW, MMO because whats the point of playing if you don't talk to other peoples and you don't interact with them, and RPG because i never found any other game that has that amount of quests/riddles ect.
I am playing what I am enjoying, when max payne came out, I was playing zelda quest on gameboy, but after a few days I came to zelda quest just because I liked it more, the graphics are not that important for me.
You said it yourself, that you prefer great 2D game over normal 3D game, so there is very little to fight over it, I fully accept it.